The genesis of Shia society, like every society, had to pass through the vicissitudes of time and place. In spite of that, the centrality and uniformity of the Shia society not only remained intact but it also flourished. The Shia society, while passing through difficult times comprising various situations like lust for leadership, adoption of wealthy and luxurious lifestyle, was emerging out victorious thereby breaking all the conspiracies, politics and abominations.
The element of leadership in these people had two aspects; one of rejection and other of confirmation. Amongst the two, the aspect of rejection was overshadowed by the solid defence of our scholars who fulfilled their responsibilities of protecting and developing our faith and keeping the path of truth always enlightened. This is because our nation has always treaded the path of truth withstanding floods of deviation, storms of satanic insinuations and polluted beliefs. We will now mention as to how a few people, amongst the storms of misguidance, started making false claims of leadership just to achieve their deceitful goals.
The Holy Infallibles (a.s.) offered sacrifices to entrench the slogan of ‘Laa Ilaaha Illa Allah Allah (There is no God but Allah)’ in the foundation of beliefs thus saving the Shia society. With regards to the aspect of rejection, history is replete with incidences right from our first Imam (a.s.) however, for the sake of brevity, we will limit our discussion to period of our last Imam (a.s.). We will analyse the conditions prevailing at that time and discuss about those self-interested people who portrayed themselves as leaders to achieve their false aims.
Our last Leader (a.s.) is the one with two occultation; a minor occultation and a major occultation. During minor occultation itself we see abominable conspiracies were at play and certain individuals falsely claimed themselves as emissaries of the blessed Imam (a.s.) and misguided the people. It was due to the blessings of Imam (a.s.) and the learned scholars that the mask of hypocrisy was removed from the faces of such disgusting individuals.
We would like to draw the attention of our esteemed readers towards those individuals who falsely claimed themselves as emissaries to Imam Mahdi (a.s.) due to their lust for power and thus traded off their world for an everlasting hell in the hereafter.
In this article, our objective is to establish three things:
- The existence of these false claimants, by itself is the strongest argument of the existence of Imam Mahdi (a.s.) because these claimants have expressly claimed to be in contact with Imam Mahdi (a.s.).
- Before claiming themselves as emissaries of Imam (a.s.), these false claimants held a high position in the society. Such a deviation after being guided is a warning for us that we should constantly recite the following verse of Holy Quran:
“Our Lord! Make not our hearts to deviate after You have guided us, and grant us from You Mercy; surely You are the most liberal Giver.”[1]
And as per the recommendation of Imam Jafar Sadiq (a.s.), we must habituate ourselves to regularly recite Dua-e-Ghareeq:
“O Allah! O All Beneficent! O All Merciful! O the Transformer of the hearts! Make my heart firm on Your religion.”[2]
- During the major occultation, it is our responsibility that we be aware of such group of false claimants and Imam-e-Zamana (a.t.f.s.) has himself emphasized that we distance ourselves from them and make every possible effort to reject them.
The rightful emissaries of Imam-e-Zamana (a.t.f.s.), known as ‘Nawwaab-e-Arbaa’ (The Four Deputies), lived such a secret life that they were, apparently, seen as oil traders but had a strong hold on the rope of faith. They worked arduously to establish the link between the people and Imam (a.s.). They were trustworthy individuals who, due to their belief, piety, sacrifice and worship, had earned proximity to Imam (a.s.).
Ameerul Momineen, Imam Ali ibn Abi Talib (a.s.) says:
“An Imam, whether apparent or hidden, discharges the duty of guidance in the best possible manner.”[3]
Imam-e-Zamana (a.t.f.s.) says:
“If you seek guidance, you will be guided.”
Let us consider a great example of faith and submission. During the last moments of Janab Husain ibn Rauh (a.r.), the third deputy of Imam Mahdi (a.s.), a person Ahmad ibn Matteel was seated near his head and Janab Ali ibn Mohammad Saimuri (a.r.), the fourth and last deputy of Imam Mahdi (a.s.), was seated near his feet. This was due to the fact that amongst these two trustworthy people, Ahmad ibn Matteel was known to be more pious and very close to Imam Mahdi (a.s.). However, when the blessed ‘Tauqee’ was received mentioning about the deputyship of Janab Ali ibn Mohammad Saimuri (a.r.), it was the high morals of Ahmad ibn Matteel that he stood up from his place and made Janab Ali ibn Mohammad Saimuri (a.r.) sit in his place and himself sat near his feet. Such personalities were free from jealousy, greed and avarice.
“O Lord! If evil tendencies are found amongst us, then for the sake of the Master of our Time (a.s.), please rectify them so that our Shia society can keep progressing under the leadership of Imam-e-Zamana (a.t.f.s.).”
Sheikh Tusi (a.r.) and other scholars have stated the following reasons for the absence of any such false claimants during the era of the first deputy Janab Usmaan ibn Saeed al-Amri (a.r.):
- The political situation during that era was such that as soon as the government got the news of anyone claiming deputyship, he would be ordered to be killed. Hence, out of fear, no one dared to make a false claim.
- The personality of Janab Usmaan ibn Saeed al-Amri (a.r.) was so exalted and noble amongst the Shias that anyone who would challenge him would face nothing but humiliation. This was due to the fact that he (a.r.) was also the representative of Imam Mohammad Taqi (a.s.), Imam Ali Naqi (a.s.) and Imam Hasan Askari (a.s.).
- People of that time were not accustomed to the concept of communicating with Imam through his deputies. This trend started after the era of the first deputy.[4]
Below, we will mention a few of those false claimants of the deputyship of Imam-e-Zamana (a.s.) that our scholars have cited from the period of the second deputy in minor occultation. For further details in this regard, one can refer to the book “Behaarul Anwaar” and its Persian translation named “Mahdi Mau’ood” by Ali Dawaani Chp. 22, pg. 697-718.
(1) Abu Mohammad Hasan Sharee’i
Abu Mohammad Hasan Sharee’i tops the list of false claimants. He is commonly known as Sharee’i as mentioned by Shaikh Tusi (a.s.), in his book ‘Al-Ghaibah’. Some scholars like Abu Mohammad Tal’akbari and Abu Ali Mohammad ibn Hammaam have included him amongst the companions and adherents of Imam Ali Naqi (a.s.) and Imam Hasan Askari (a.s.). Abu Mohammad Tal’akbari narrates that it was after the manifestation of disbelief and atheism of Hasan Sharae’i that all the false claimants started fabricating lies to Imam (a.s.) and claimed that they were his deputy.
And in this way, he could successfully trap a few people with weak beliefs in the society. His corrupt beliefs like ‘Wahdatul Wujood’, based on the beliefs of Mansoor Hallaaj and Shalmaghaani, came to the fore. He has been cursed in one of the letters (Tauqee) of Imam Mahdi (a.t.f.s.).[5]
(2) Mohammad ibn Naseer Numairi
Ibn Nuh narrates that Abu Nasr Hebatullah ibn Mohammad said to me that Mohammad ibn Naseer Numairi was amongst the companions of Imam Hasan Askari (a.s.). As soon as Janab Usmaan ibn Saeed al- Amri (a.r.) left for the heavenly abode, he claimed that “I am the deputy of Imam of the time”. Abu Talib says that as soon as Janab Mohammad ibn Usmaan ibn Saeed al-Amri (a.r.) was apprised of the corrupt belief of Mohammad ibn Naseer Numairi, he cursed him and distanced himself from him to such an extent that when Numairi expressed his desire to meet him, he kept himself hidden from him.
Saad ibn Abdullah Ashari narrates that Numairi believed in reincarnation. He considered Imam Ali Naqi (a.s.) as God (God forbid) and himself as His messenger. He considered relations with the ladies of the house (sister and mother) and homosexuality as permissible. Mohammad ibn Musa ibn Hasan ibn Furat, a minister of high rank of Muqtadir Billah Abbasi, says that Numairi used to say that God has not prohibited these acts on any of his servants. Saeed ibn Abdullah says that at the time of his death, he named Ahmad as his successor and thereafter the society was divided into three factions.[6]
Dear Readers! Have you noticed that if Allah leaves us on our own condition then we would never know in which abyss of deviation we would fall into. The founder of this organization Hujjatul Islam wal Muslimeen Al-Hajj Shaikh Ismail Rajabi (may Allah elevate his status) often mentioned that as and when a person scales new heights, he requires stronger support because there is higher risk of falling down thereby leading to severe injuries.
(3) Ahmad ibn Hilaal Karkhi
Abu Ali ibn Hammaam narrates that Ahmad ibn Hilaal Karkhi was amongst the companions of Imam Hasan Askari (a.s.). Till the era of Imam Hasan Askari (a.s.), all the Shias believed that after the demise of Janab Usmaan ibn Saeed al-Amri (a.r.), his son Janab Mohammad ibn Usmaan ibn Saeed al-Amri (a.r.) would be the deputy of Imam Mahdi (a.t.f.s.). However, after the demise of Janab Usmaan ibn Saeed al-Amri (a.r.), Ahmad ibn Hilaal Karkhi claimed to be the deputy and proclaimed that I have not heard anything from Imam Hasan Askari (a.s.) regarding the appointment of Mohammad ibn Usmaan (a.r.) as a deputy. The people said that many trustworthy people have heard about it but Ahmad refused and said “Those who have heard can believe but I do not believe”. Through the medium of Janab Husain ibn Rauh Nawbakhti (a.r.), a “Tauqee” was received from Imam-e-Zamana (a.t.f.s.) in which Imam (a.s.) cursed him and admonished people to distance themselves from him.[7]
(4) Abu Tahir Mohammad ibn Ali ibn Bilaal
He is also included among the false claimants of deputyship of Imam Mahdi (a.t.f.s.). After his false claim, he started collecting religious dues of Khums and Zakaat from an adherent of Imam (a.s.) and said that Imam (a.s.) has permitted him to do so. Abul Hasan Mohammad ibn Mohammad ibn Yahya Ma’azi, popularly known as Abu Ghalib Zuraari, has narrated his story in detail and has proved that in spite of the order of Imam-e-Zamana (a.t.f.s.), he did not handover the collected money to Janab Mohammad ibn Usmaan (a.r.).[8]
(5) Husain ibn Mansoor Hallaaj
Shaikh Tusi (a.r.) has narrated that when Allah intended to humiliate Husain ibn Mansoor Hallaaj, He exposed his corrupt beliefs. He wrote a letter to Abu Sahl, a well-known and respected person in Baghdad from the family Nawbakht, stating that “I am the deputy of Imam-e-Zamana (a.t.f.s.). Do not think that I need any favour from you but I am writing to you just to inform you about it. Do not deny me.” On receipt of the letter, Abu Sahl gave him a humorous reply:
“I will not deny you but you miraculously solve a problem of mine. The problem is that my hair and beard have turned white and I have to frequently dye it. Since I have many bondmaids, it takes a lot of time to hide my white hair in order to fulfil their needs. Therefore, you turn my hair permanently black.”
As soon as he read this reply, Hallaaj understood that he had made a mockery of his claim.
A group of scholars have narrated from the brother of Shaikh Saduq (a.r.) that the son of Hallaaj brought a letter to my father in Qum. As soon as he received the letter, he tore it into pieces in front of the messenger and asked his servants to lead him outside the house.[9]
(6) Mohammad ibn Ali Shalmaghaani
Mohammad ibn Ali Shalmaghaani is one of the most nefarious names amongst the false claimant of deputyship of Imam-e-Zamana (a.t.f.s.). He is also known as ‘ibne Abi Azaaqir’. His detailed account has been narrated by ibne Aseer Jazari in the 2nd volume of his book “Al-Kaamil fi al-Taarikh” as follows:
Shaikh Tusi (a.r.) narrates from Janab Umme Kulsum, daughter of Janab Mohammad ibn Usmaan (a.r.) and a very noble and a pious lady, who narrates that Shalmaghaani was very respected amongst the tribe of Bustaam because Janab Husain ibn Rauh (a.r.) used to accord him a lot of respect. Shalmaghaani took undue advantage of this and slandered Janab Husain ibn Rauh (a.r.) in the tribe of Bustaam by saying that he (a.r.) has asked him to hide all his shortcomings and hence, he accords him so much respect. The tribesmen also accepted his argument. When this news reached Janab Husain ibn Rauh (a.r.), not only did he deny such claims but also cursed him and advised people to distance themselves from him because it was during these times that Shalmaghaani started propagating ideas of ‘Ghuluw’ (Exaggeration) and ‘Hulool’ (Manifestation of God in humans). However, the tribesmen did not believe in it. Janab Husain ibn Rauh (a.r.) wrote a letter to the Shias informing them about the evils of Shalmaghaani, cursed him and urged on distancing themselves from him. Thereafter, a ‘Tauqee’ was received from Imam Mahdi (a.t.f.s.) in which he (a.s.) clearly cursed him, those who followed him, those who were pleased with him and moreover, those who maintained friendship and relations with him even after the receipt of this ‘Tauqee’. And he (a.s.) ordered all these people to stay away from him.
The scholars have also called him a ‘Sufi’. In the year 322-323 A.H., he was executed by the Abbasid caliph ‘Ar-Raazi Billah’ and hence Shias were saved from his evil.[10]
Besides above, there are a few more names in the list of false claimants of deputyship of Imam Mahdi (a.t.f.s.). But for the sake of brevity, we are just quoting two more names as follows:
- Abu Bakr Baghdadi also known as Abu Dalaf Majnoon and believed in ‘Ghuluw’ (Exaggeration) and ‘Mukhammasan’ (Sufism).
- Mohammad ibn Ali Bilaal Bilaali.
In the end, it is necessary to reiterate that these false claimants are not only a proof of the existence of Imam Mahdi (a.t.f.s.) but also their false claims emphasize on the importance of the position of deputyship of Imam (a.s.).
“We supplicate to the Lord of the Worlds that He brings this occultation to an end, blesses us with his service and in the era of occultation, give us the good fortune to defend these Holy personalities from their enemies. Aameen.”
[1] Surah Aal-e-Imran (3), verse 8
[2] Mikyaalul Makaarim, vol. 2, pg. 260, 607
[3] Nahjul Balagha
[4] Taareekh-e-Ghaibat-e-Sughra, Shaikh Tusi (a.s.)
[5] Mahdi Mau’ood, pg. 697-698
[6] Mahdi Mau’ood, pg. 698-699
[7] Mahdi Mau’ood, pg. 699
[8] Mahdi Mau’ood, pg. 699-701
[9] Mahdi Mau’ood, pg. 701-704
[10] Mahdi Mau’ood, pg. 704-714
